Mail filter not working as expected

I need to create a “do-not-reply” email (do-not-reply@mydomain.com) so that it can be used on my wordpress website.

So after creating this email, I login using usermin, under filter and forward mail I set to:

For:

  • all email
  • throw away

or

  • all email
  • send to trash

however if I send an email to this do-not-reply@mydomain.com it goes to the inbox instead throwing it away / go to trash.