How to enable the same Let's Encrypt SSL certificate on automatically created subdomains on a LARAVEL multi-tenant project?

Here are the steps I follow by checking “Also request wildcard certificate?”:

And here’s the screenshot of the _acme_challenge.domain.name error from the following screenshot:

What step did I miss that caused this to fail???
And how can I prevent the renewal issue I had here: How to update my "Let's Encrypt Wildcard SSL Certificat" AUTOMATICALLY when it expired? from recurring???