domain names and :10000 help

I have a server I am running at home that shares a IP address with all the virtual servers I create.

When I type in the URL and the :10000 it always says “This web server is running in SSL mode. Try the URL instead”.

How can I get it to change to the other virtual server I am using instead of defaulting to the first one?
EX would be not just

You should be able to configure the hostname it presents in that message in Webmin -> Webmin Configuration -> Ports and Addresses : Web server hostname.

Or you could have it redirect immediately to HTTPS instead of showing that message, under Webmin -> Webmin Configuration -> SSL Encryption : Redirect non-SSL requests….